MLB Monday is back with another entry in the Gold Glove miniseries: the National League “winners” in the Decade of Grunge. And some of these winners—well, most of them, really—were really grungy. We actually have a “Bottom 11” today, plus two (dis)Honorable Mentions—this is a brutal decade for bad votes. In fairness, though, many them are borderline bad, with only a few truly horrible decisions by the collective.

Here are the “worst” NL GG winners of the Nineties, in reverse order:

DM. Tim Wallach, 3B, 1990 (0.0 dWAR): He finished his solid career with 10.5 dWAR, but this specific season, he was very average. In his other two GG vote-win seasons (1985, 1988), he combined to put up 5.0 dWAR, however. In the year before this one, he posted 1.1 dWAR, and the year after? He was in the black with 0.3 dWAR. So, we can forgive the voters for this one, since, again, he was not a “bad” glove man in 1990.

DM. Darren Lewis, CF, 1994 (0.0 dWAR): He famously set a record for playing his first 391 MLB games without an error, which gave a false belief he was actually a good glove man. But of course, his range was limited/mediocre, as he posted -1.0 dWAR combined in 1991 and 1992, for example. In 1993, though, he did earn 1.0 dWAR. But in 1994, he made two errors, was an average defender, and won the GG vote anyway.

11. Jeff Bagwell, 1B, 1994 (-0.1 dWAR): Classic example of the offensive explosion leading voters to just give away a Gold Glove. He managed -7.2 dWAR for his career, so no one would ever claim he was good on defense, and this season isn’t too bad, obviously. But clearly he had no business winning the vote. He won the NL MVP vote in this strike-shortened season, so the voters probably were just really lazy and detached.

10. Mark Grace, 1B, 1992/1995 (0.0/-0.2 dWAR): He did win a “legit” GG vote in 1993 with 0.2 dWAR, but overall, he was mediocre with the glove work (-5.0 dWAR career). Not so coincidentally, he posted 11.0 oWAR in the three GG seasons combined, so we’re sure that had something to do with him winning the votes in these two undeserving years. He got better after posting -3.3 dWAR in his first two seasons, though.

9. Andrés Galarraga, 1B, 1990 (-0.3 dWAR): He was higher—or is it lower?—on our NL 1980s list, but this second-straight GG vote win for the Big Cat was still not appropriate. For a guy who ended up 14.9 dWAR underwater by the end of his career, it’s laughable to think he won this award twice. He actually never played a full season with a positive dWAR mark. Never. Ever. We wonder if voters even realized this, eh?

8. Andy Van Slyke, CF, 1990-1992 (0.0/-0.3/-0.1 dWAR): Like some of the above, these are not bad votes, as he posted 2.5 dWAR combined in 1988-1989 while winning the vote in those two years. He certainly was known for his big arm, though, more than his mobility, and he also played alongside a GG left fielder for these three years, which made his range less important in center. Still, he should not have won these awards.

7. Craig Biggio, 2B, 1994 (-0.4 dWAR): This was the first of four consecutive GG wins for him at second base, but it is a head scratcher. He combined for just -0.1 dWAR in his first two seasons at the position (1992-1993) after switching from catcher, so he didn’t have a reputation or anything. However, the next three years saw him posted a combined 3.0 dWAR in winning the subsequent votes, so there’s that fact.

6. Bret Boone, 2B, 1998 (-0.4 dWAR): An up-and-down glove man his whole career, he later won three straight AL GG votes. But this was his first, and it clearly was not warranted. He had compiled 0.7 dWAR from 1992-1997, demonstrating he was barely above average in the field. His oWAR wasn’t a career best in this season, either, so we’re not sure what the voters were seeing. It wouldn’t be the first time we’re confused.

5. Will Clark, 1B, 1991 (-0.8 dWAR): This surprises us, as we were brainwashed to think he was a slick fielder back in the day. But his career dWAR (-10.1) is painful to look at now. His offensive season was average during this year, and the only season he ever posted positive dWAR as a regular player was in 1997 with Texas. This was the only Gold Glove he ever won, and again, we’re not sure why it happened. Oh well!

4. Ken Caminiti, 3B, 1995/1997 (-1.0/-1.0 dWAR): Another nail in his PED coffin, sadly, as in the years prior to his 1995 vote win here, he posted 6.0 dWAR in Houston. But his move to San Diego with a PED-enabling manager meant more bulk and a resulting drop in defensive performance. His Padres career resulting in these two GG vote wins despite a -2.6 dWAR overall in those four seasons. May he rest in peace.

3. Larry Walker, RF, 1998-1999 (-0.5/-1.2 dWAR): He posted 2.9 dWAR in Montréal from 1989-1994 combined, which included two legit GGs in 1992-1993. And he did win three other “legit” GGs in Colorado (1997, 2001-2002 with an aggregate 1.4 dWAR). But these two vote wins were not deserved. His career 2.0 dWAR shows a rollercoaster ride in the outfield for him, and the voters realized it a year too late, really.

2. J.T. Snow, 1B, 1997-1999 (-1.3/-0.5/-0.7 dWAR): Not only was he in our AL 1990s dishonor roll, but he will be in our NL 2000s as well. He won six consecutive GG votes despite a combined -6.5 dWAR in those seasons without a single year in the black. His career dWAR (-10.8) is shameful. Not sure what we can say here that we have not already stated before now. He had one season overall that was positive dWAR (2003).

1. Steve Finley, CF, 1995 (-1.8 dWAR): In his four seasons with the Astros prior to this season, he posted 5.1 dWAR and did not win a Gold Glove. Then somehow, he goes to San Diego with the same aforementioned PED-enabling manager, adds bulk, becomes a truly lousy defender, and wins the GG vote. Defies logic, for sure. He compiled -4.6 dWAR with the Padres over four seasons, demonstrating a downside of muscling up.